This Trenton restaurant has been serving up delicious Italian food for generations

With mouthwatering pasta dishes, and steaks served in Grandma’s mystery sauce, you can really sense the love at Sibley Gardens in Trenton.

“It’s an Italian steakhouse, but it’s substantially a lot more than that,” explains co-proprietor Nick Piunti. “The very best compliment, and I’ve listened to it so lots of situations as a result of my career right here, is ‘I’ve in no way experienced a terrible food [here].’ The regularity, I assume, is what we’re truly acknowledged for.”

It was initially crafted in 1935 on the other facet of the street, close to the place a large amount of Italian immigrants in the location retained their gardens, as a result the title. The Piunti relatives acquired it in 1944, but left the operations to somebody else. In 1961 Mary and Sam Piunti, Nick’s grandmother and father, took it around and designed it their individual.

“So my Dad would cope with the entrance of the dwelling, and Grandmother taken care of the again of the residence,” suggests Nick. ” She immigrated to the nation when she was 15, learned from the cooks that she worked with. It was kind of like a small Italy in this region.”


Numerous of her recipes are however served nowadays, together with their renowned Steak Sammy. Sam, Nick’s father, would question his mother to make the dish when he was doing work. It was steak cooked in a pink wine and garlic au jus. Buyers would arrive by and see him eating it, and commenced inquiring for it, so they put it on the menu.

So far, 4 generations of Nick Piunti’s family members have worked at Sibley Gardens. Sam Piunti continue to stops by the cafe each and every day, Nick is also there jogging the put, and Jake, Nick’s nephew, heads up their bar plan.

The restaurant has an intimate, stylish ambiance exactly where everyone’s addressed like loved ones. Nick states they have some regulars that occur a few situations a 7 days, whilst other people could not visualize acquiring their birthday celebration anyplace else.

“We have kitchen area employees that begun here as dishwashers 20 yrs ago, and are now the sous chef. So I am very pleased of the reality that people today want to perform here for that prolonged,” suggests Nick.


Even though the menu has altered above the years, they nevertheless serve loads of steaks and Italian favorites. If you are in the temper for pasta, try their Mediterranean pasta with creamy goat cheese sauce, olives, tomatoes, spinach, and a minor little bit of parsley. For a twist on Hen Piccata, check out their Chicken Sonoma which is a sautéed chicken breast in a white wine and lemon sauce served with artichokes, solar-dried tomatoes, and capers.

For the full story and a lot more of what is on the menu, view the movie higher than.

Sibley Gardens is positioned at 916 W Jefferson Avenue in Trenton.

Copyright 2022 by WDIV ClickOnDetroit – All legal rights reserved.